Short answer

Saxon Math fits families that want a low-cost print program with deep daily review and are willing to teach and grade. Teaching Textbooks fits families that want math to run independently, with video instruction and automatic grading built into an online platform the student works through alone.

Disclosure. Some links on this page are affiliate links. Every Homeschool may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. Editorial picks are not influenced by commissions; see how we make money.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Visit www.hmhco.comVisit teachingtextbooks.com

Saxon Math and Teaching Textbooks are two homeschool math choices, and they sit at opposite ends of the parent-involvement spectrum. Saxon Math is the print incremental-spiral curriculum: each lesson introduces a small new concept and then mixes practice of earlier concepts into a daily problem set the parent checks. Teaching Textbooks is a self-paced online program where each lesson delivers a video lecture, worked examples, and auto-graded homework, with a parent dashboard that tracks progress. Saxon covers kindergarten through Calculus; Teaching Textbooks covers Math 3 through Pre-Calculus. The pedagogical question is how much of the teaching and grading the parent wants to own.

Decision rubric, side by side

Saxon Math wins 3. Teaching Textbooks wins 2. Tied on 2.

Scroll the table sideways

DimensionSaxon MathTeaching TextbooksWinner
FormatPrint textbook and worksheetsOnline platform with video lessonsTie
Grade coverageKindergarten through CalculusMath 3 through Pre-CalculusSaxon Math
GradingParent checks daily work by handAutomatic grading built into the platformTeaching Textbooks
Parent teaching loadModerate (parent presents lessons, checks work)Low (video teaches, platform grades)Teaching Textbooks
Pedagogical methodIncremental spiral with heavy daily reviewLesson-and-practice with lighter cumulative reviewSaxon Math
Reusability across childrenReusable print books (consumable worktexts at lower grades)Per-student subscription or product; reusable within license termsSaxon Math
Best forFamilies wanting low cost and deep review who will teach and gradeFamilies wanting independent, self-grading math with minimal parent timeTie

When to pick Saxon Math

Pick Saxon Math if you want a print program with deep daily review and are comfortable presenting lessons and checking work, if the budget favors reusable physical books over per-student subscriptions, or if the child benefits from the routine and consistent cumulative practice Saxon is built around. Saxon also goes further up the sequence than Teaching Textbooks, running through Calculus, so a family that wants one publisher from kindergarten through high school can stay in Saxon the whole way.

Visit www.hmhco.comRead full review

When to pick Teaching Textbooks

Pick Teaching Textbooks if you want math to run with minimal parent involvement, if automatic grading and a progress dashboard matter because the parent has limited time or several children, or if the child does better watching a video lesson and getting immediate feedback than working from a print page. Teaching Textbooks is also the right pick when a reluctant or math-anxious student responds better to the gentler, self-paced online format than to Saxon’s heavier daily worksheet load.

Visit teachingtextbooks.comRead full review

Verdict

In our assessment, both produce capable math students, and the decision is operational more than pedagogical. Saxon wins on cost, on grade ceiling (it runs through Calculus), and on depth of daily review. Teaching Textbooks wins on parent time, on self-grading, and on independent student use.

Where to buy Saxon Math

The publisher’s own site is below, plus the retailers that typically carry it new, and the used market. Each link is a search for Saxon Math, so the price you see is whatever the retailer is charging today. We list retailers by availability, never by commission.

Some links below are affiliate links. How we make money.

Visit hmhco.com

  • Christianbook

    Largest Christian-homeschool catalog

    Search
  • Rainbow Resource

    Secular + Christian homeschool retailer

    Search
  • Bookshop.org

    Indie-bookstore network (10% commission supports indie shops) (affiliate)

    Search
  • Westminster Bookstore

    Reformed-Presbyterian theology and homeschool resources

    Search
  • Amazon

    Wide selection, fast shipping (affiliate)

    Search

Used market

  • eBay

    Used and resold homeschool curriculum

    Search
  • ThriftBooks

    Second-hand books, often the cheapest copies

    Search

Where to buy Teaching Textbooks

The publisher’s own site is below, plus the retailers that typically carry it new, and the used market. Each link is a search for Teaching Textbooks, so the price you see is whatever the retailer is charging today. We list retailers by availability, never by commission.

Some links below are affiliate links. How we make money.

Visit teachingtextbooks.com

  • Christianbook

    Largest Christian-homeschool catalog

    Search
  • Rainbow Resource

    Secular + Christian homeschool retailer

    Search
  • Bookshop.org

    Indie-bookstore network (10% commission supports indie shops) (affiliate)

    Search
  • Westminster Bookstore

    Reformed-Presbyterian theology and homeschool resources

    Search
  • Amazon

    Wide selection, fast shipping (affiliate)

    Search

Used market

  • eBay

    Used and resold homeschool curriculum

    Search
  • ThriftBooks

    Second-hand books, often the cheapest copies

    Search

Read the Math pillar guide for the broader comparison

The Math guide covers the broader field of math curricula. Read the Math pillar guide

More homeschool-curriculum comparisons