About
The Lost Tools of Writing is developed and published by the CiRCE Institute. CiRCE says the program trains students in the classical art of rhetoric, with the persuasive essay as the primary form. Level I covers primarily the persuasive essay, Level II studies the judicial address, and Level III centers on the deliberative address. CiRCE offers teacher training.
The Every Homeschool rubric review
Our deep read on The Lost Tools of Writing (CiRCE)
Disclosure. Some links on this page are affiliate links. Every Homeschool may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. Editorial picks are not influenced by commissions; see how we make money.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Lost Tools of Writing is the CiRCE Institute's writing program, which trains students in the classical art of rhetoric.
Last updated: 2026-10-29 · Every Homeschool Editorial Team
At a glance
| Method | Classical (rhetoric-based) |
| Worldview | Christian, denomination not stated (Every Homeschool classification); the CiRCE Institute's About page says it is "committed to the Christianity expressed in the historic creeds of the church" |
| Grades | Grades 7 to 10 as described by CiRCE; Level I recommended for age 12 and up |
| Formats | Print text and workbook; streaming video; live online courses |
| Cost tier | Premium |
| Parent intensity | 4 |
| ESA-common | Not verified; confirm with your state program before purchase |
| Accredited | Not applicable; this is a curriculum, not an accredited school |
| Established | Not stated for the program; the CiRCE Institute dates itself to 1996 |
| Website | circeinstitute.org |
Our scoreboard (1-5)
| Criterion | Score | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|
| Academic rigor | 5 | In our assessment, an intellectually serious writing program |
| Ease of teaching | 2 | In our assessment, requires parent investment in the method; CiRCE offers teacher training |
| Content quality | 5 | In our assessment, a tight conceptual framework and substantive materials |
| Flexibility | 3 | In our assessment, can serve as the writing block alongside another curriculum, but follows its own method |
| Value for money | 3 | The Level I Complete Set is listed at $157.00 (see cost section); in our assessment, easier to justify for families committed to the method |
| Worldview scope | 4 | Christian; the CiRCE Institute's About page says it is "committed to the Christianity expressed in the historic creeds of the church" |
| Visual/design | 4 | In our assessment, clean and professional in design |
| Support resources | 5 | Video, live six-week intensives, conferences and podcasts from CiRCE |
Who the publisher is
The CiRCE Institute says it began in 1996 as Circe Ministries, a research and tutoring service formed by Andrew Kern, and became a nonprofit corporation in 2002. Its About page describes an annual conference, in-house teacher training, Lost Tools of Writing materials and workshops, and consulting, and gives its acronym as Center for Independent Research on Classical Education. The CiRCE store lists its address as Kannapolis, North Carolina.
The Lost Tools of Writing is sold in three levels, which CiRCE describes as ideal for students in seventh through tenth grade, with Level I a one- or two-year program covering primarily the persuasive essay. CiRCE says the program trains students in the classical art of rhetoric and teaches the proper form of persuasive writing.
CiRCE's webinars and intensives page lists a free Lost Tools of Writing Q&A webinar and six-week intensives for Levels 1 and 2 led by CiRCE instructors.
The core pedagogy
The Lost Tools of Writing, per CiRCE, trains students in the classical art of rhetoric and teaches the proper form of persuasive writing, with Level I covering primarily the persuasive essay. CiRCE's skills list for Level I names exordium, division, narratio, thesis, proofs, arguments, refutation, conclusion, and amplification. CiRCE lists the common topics taught in Level I as definition, comparison, circumstance, testimony, and relationship.
In our assessment, the scope and sequence goes deep on one form rather than wide across many. Level I is, per CiRCE, a one or two-year program, depending on the age of the student and the pace, that covers primarily the persuasive essay. Level I features eight essays and a review lesson, according to CiRCE. In our assessment, the essays are exercises in generating arguments from the topics rather than in personal opinion. According to CiRCE, Level II studies the judicial address, which refines the persuasive essay taught in Level I, and Level III centers on the deliberative address, which determines whether an action should be taken (Level pages).
Signature mechanics: (1) Invention through the topics: CiRCE lists the common topics (definition, comparison, circumstance, testimony, relationship) among the thinking skills taught in Level I. (2) Persuasive essay as central form: Level I covers primarily the persuasive essay, and the later levels turn to the judicial and deliberative addresses. (3) ANI chart: CiRCE's LTW Workshop at Home series includes a part titled "The ANI Chart" and one titled "From ANI to Outline." (4) Teacher training: CiRCE's LTW Workshop at Home series is led by the director of Lost Tools of Writing and offers "the same sort of training you would find at any LTW workshop."
The parent role
In our assessment, the parent's role is substantial. In our assessment, The Lost Tools of Writing is a method that the parent needs to understand well enough to coach, not a fill-in-the-blank workbook. In our assessment, parents can run the program from the teacher's guide, and may get more from it after attending a CiRCE conference or taking a CiRCE training course. Families who cannot commit that time can instead look at the six-week Lost Tools of Writing courses that CiRCE instructors lead.
What they do exceptionally well
Systematic invention. In our assessment, The Lost Tools of Writing teaches students how to generate arguments rather than assuming they already have something to say. In our assessment, students who complete Level I come out able to generate multiple lines of argument on unfamiliar questions.
Intellectual seriousness. In our assessment, the curriculum treats its students as capable of real thought.
Support infrastructure. CiRCE's offerings include teacher training, a national conference and a regional conference, live six-week Lost Tools of Writing intensives, and podcasts, which in our assessment means a family using The Lost Tools of Writing is not working alone if they do not want to be.
What they do poorly
Parent demand. CiRCE's Level I Complete Set includes a Teacher's Guide of over 200 pages of lesson guides and a subscription to streaming instructional videos, and its LTW Workshop at Home series offers parent training at home. In our assessment, the program works best with a parent who has read the teacher's guide carefully and can coach an adolescent through generating arguments. In our assessment, parents who want to hand a student a workbook and check answers may struggle.
Cost stack. The Level I Complete Set bundles a teacher guide, a student workbook, and streaming videos; in our assessment, adding teacher training, a live course, and conferences adds to the cost of the set.
Who it fits / who it doesn't
Pick The Lost Tools of Writing if: you want classical rhetoric as the frame for writing instruction; you can invest in teacher training or a live course; you value depth over breadth of form; your student is a middle-school or high-school writer ready for intellectual work; you want a curriculum that treats composition as thinking, not expression; you are part of or can join a classical co-op where other families using The Lost Tools of Writing are working.
Skip The Lost Tools of Writing if: you want open-and-go writing with minimal parent preparation; you want variety of forms (narrative, descriptive, research paper) from day one, since Level I covers primarily the persuasive essay and the later levels study the judicial and deliberative addresses; your student is elementary-age (CiRCE describes the program as ideal for seventh through tenth grade); you want a secular writing program with no classical-Christian framing; you are price-sensitive and cannot take on the full stack.
Cost honest assessment
CiRCE's Lost Tools of Writing page, retrieved October 2026, lists the Level I Complete Set at $157.00 (a teacher guide, a student workbook, and a subscription to streaming videos, per the product page), or separately a $47.00 student workbook, an $87.00 teacher guide, and $45.00 videos. It lists the Level II Complete Set at $157.00 and the Level III Complete Set at $67.00 (retrieved October 2026). The product page says a student workbook must be purchased for each student who uses the program.
Where to buy
Buy or enroll from the publisher's store: circeinstitute.org.
ESA eligibility notes
The Lost Tools of Writing is published by CiRCE Institute and includes curriculum materials and live online courses. Each program sets its own eligible categories: Arizona's statute allows "Curricula and supplementary materials" (A.R.S. 15-2402); the Step Up For Students Personalized Education Program handbook lists "Curriculum and curriculum materials" among eligible expense categories (PEP Family Handbook); Utah's statute names "textbooks, curricula, or other instructional materials" as scholarship expenses (Utah Code 53F-6-401); and the Arkansas Department of Education lists "curricula" among eligible 2026-2027 expenses (service provider page). Whether a program treats a live online course as curriculum, tuition or tutoring depends on the program; confirm with your program administrator that the Lost Tools materials and the live course component are eligible before ordering.
Alternatives
- Institute for Excellence in Writing Structure and Style, a family might pick IEW if they want a teacher seminar and workbook approach; IEW describes Teaching Writing: Structure and Style as moving from rewriting a paragraph into advanced essay writing, and says students learn to write "cohesive paragraphs, reports, essays, and critiques."
- Classical Academic Press Writing and Rhetoric, a family might pick CAP because Writing and Rhetoric is a graded series of books, from Book 1: Fable to Book 11: Thesis Part 2 on CAP's collection page.
- Memoria Press Classical Composition, a family might pick Memoria Press's Classical Composition, which Memoria says is based on "the original classical method of teaching writing called the 'progymnasmata.'"
Signature products
- Five canons of rhetoric
- Persuasive essay central form
- CiRCE teacher training emphasis
Keep reading
Compare The Lost Tools of Writing (CiRCE) with other publishers.
Independent analysis of publishers like The Lost Tools of Writing (CiRCE) and the many others across every method and worldview, open to everyone. No email. No paywall.