Disclosure. Some links on this page are affiliate links. Every Homeschool may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. Editorial picks are not influenced by commissions; see how we make money.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Introduction
In our assessment, handwriting is easy to treat as an afterthought, a few minutes of letter tracing squeezed between reading and math. The research below, in our assessment, supports taking it more seriously. In a neuroimaging study of five-year-old pre-literate children, a reading-related brain circuit was recruited during letter perception after the children had printed letters by hand, but not after they had typed or traced them (James & Engelhardt, 2012, “The effects of handwriting experience on functional brain development in pre-literate children,” Trends in Neuroscience and Education). In our assessment, for a parent choosing a first program, the practical question is less which brand is best and more which format to start in, how much teacher preparation the program demands, and whether the daily lesson is short enough to actually happen.
Key takeaways
- 01Handwriting instruction has benefits for early literacy development. The University of Iowa’s Iowa Reading Research Center notes that the visual recognition of letters and the physical motion of producing them activate the same brain region, and that the fine-motor skills of letter formation are associated with early reading achievement (Iowa Reading Research Center, 2019).
- 02In our assessment, format is a parent decision. The Iowa center describes teaching letters in formation families, groups of letters that need similar motions or strokes, for both capital and lowercase letters (Iowa Reading Research Center, 2019).
- 03Multisensory, manipulative-first programs like Handwriting Without Tears and Logic of English are, in our assessment, a good fit for younger writers and children with fine-motor difficulty.
- 04Workbook-driven programs like The Good and the Beautiful, A Reason for Handwriting, and Pentime, in our assessment, ask little teacher prep and run on low-cost consumables.
- 05Classical homeschools are, in our assessment, well served by Memoria Press copybooks, in which students copy Scripture, maxims, poetry, and other literature selections (Memoria Press, Copybooks I-III Set, retrieved October 2026).
Print vs. cursive: what the sources say
An NPR Shots report on handwriting research states that, so far, the evidence suggests that writing by hand is what matters, not whether it is print or cursive (NPR Shots, May 11, 2024).
Logic of English, which sells Rhythm of Handwriting in both manuscript and cursive, lists among its reasons to teach cursive that continuous strokes mean students lift the pencil only between words and that in Rhythm of Handwriting all lowercase letters begin on the baseline, and among its reasons to teach manuscript that manuscript more closely matches the style of fonts found in books (Logic of English, Rhythm of Handwriting, retrieved October 2026). The Iowa Reading Research Center describes teaching letters in formation families and notes that when formal instruction begins in pre-kindergarten or kindergarten it can be easier for children to learn capital letters first (Iowa Reading Research Center, 2019).
In our assessment, the format is still a real fork for curriculum shopping, because the programs below differ in whether they offer print, cursive, or a transition between the two. Decide the format before the brand.
How to choose
In our assessment, three variables separate these programs more than letterform quality does. The first is teacher load: some programs are open-and-go consumables a child can largely self-direct, while others assume a parent demonstrates each letter. The second is materials: a few programs lean on physical manipulatives and slates, most run on a workbook. The third is content tie-in, whether the practice text is neutral, Scripture-based, or drawn from classical passages a child is also memorizing.
Handwriting Without Tears
Handwriting Without Tears (now published under Learning Without Tears) is a program the publisher describes as multisensory and developmentally sequenced from Pre-K through grade 6, with print instruction targeting transitional kindergarten through grade 2 and cursive instruction running grades 2 through 6 (Learning Without Tears, retrieved October 2026). The publisher says double lines are a pivotal element of its approach, aiding children in placing letters correctly, and that its cursive style is simple and vertical instead of slanted (Learning Without Tears, Handwriting Without Tears, retrieved October 2026; Learning Without Tears history, retrieved October 2026). The publisher lists hands-on tools including Wood Pieces and the Slate for Wet-Dry-Try practice, alongside student editions and teacher’s guides (Learning Without Tears, retrieved October 2026). It does not carry an Every Homeschool detail page yet.
The Good and the Beautiful Handwriting
The Good and the Beautiful sells handwriting workbooks, and the publisher offers its full-year Language Arts levels K through 8 as free PDF downloads (The Good and the Beautiful, free language arts resources, retrieved October 2026). The handwriting line runs from pre-writing courses through level 7. Printing is the focus through levels K, 1, and 2, and cursive is introduced at level 3 using a colored-dot system: the publisher states that the level 3 workbook devotes roughly 85 percent of the course to teaching cursive and 15 percent to cementing correct print formation (The Good and the Beautiful, Handwriting Workbook Level 3, retrieved October 2026). The publisher lists its printed workbooks at $12.99 for the pre-writing parts and level K and at $15.99 for levels 1 through 7, including level 3, and the publisher says its colored-dot system in levels 3 and 4 makes it easy for children to learn cursive with little to no help from parents (The Good and the Beautiful handwriting collection, retrieved October 2026). Families for whom worldview matters should review the worldview classification on its detail page.
Logic of English Rhythm of Handwriting
Logic of English’s Rhythm of Handwriting is, in our assessment, the most explicitly multisensory of the workbook-anchored programs. It is available in manuscript or cursive (Logic of English, Rhythm of Handwriting, retrieved October 2026), and the publisher says the cursive and manuscript letters are closely related in shape and direction to facilitate ease of transition between handwriting styles (Logic of English, Rhythm of Handwriting Cursive Bundle, retrieved October 2026). The publisher says students form each letter with large-motor movements before advancing to writing with a pencil, and that the method emphasizes rhythmic motions with short, memorable phrases for how to form each letter (Logic of English, Rhythm of Handwriting, retrieved October 2026). The Cursive Bundle, which packages the student book, a quick-reference guide, tactile cards, a desk strip, and a student whiteboard, is listed at $62.06 (Logic of English, Rhythm of Handwriting Cursive Bundle, retrieved October 2026). The publisher states that Foundations lessons provide the same instruction as Rhythm of Handwriting, so families using Foundations do not need to purchase it, and that Rhythm of Handwriting is designed to be used alongside Essentials or as a stand-alone writing program (Logic of English, where to start, retrieved October 2026).
Memoria Press copybooks
Memoria Press describes copybook as a learning activity in which students copy Scripture, maxims, poetry, and other literature selections (Memoria Press, Copybooks I-III Set, retrieved October 2026). The penmanship line includes New American Cursive, which the publisher describes as presenting simplified letter forms; the publisher says its alphabet has 26 fewer strokes than the top three most common cursive programs and that its natural right slant is easier for beginners and left-handers (Memoria Press, New American Cursive, retrieved October 2026). In its Copybook Cursive series, the publisher describes Copybook Cursive Book One as its original Copybook III formatted in the New American Cursive font (Memoria Press, Copybook Cursive, retrieved October 2026). The publisher says it takes students only twenty minutes of their day to practice in their New American Cursive book (Memoria Press, New American Cursive, retrieved October 2026). In our assessment, this is a natural pick for homeschools already running a Memoria Press or classical core.
A Reason for Handwriting
A Reason for Handwriting is a handwriting curriculum from A Reason For, which describes its programs as Scripture-based (A Reason For, About Us, retrieved October 2026). The publisher describes a PreK through 6th grade program with every weekly lesson built around one Scripture verse (A Reason For, Handwriting, retrieved October 2026). The levels after kindergarten are lettered, and Level T (Transition) is recommended for grade 2 or 3 and includes both manuscript and cursive: the publisher designed the updated Transition worktext to facilitate a mid-year shift, with students reviewing manuscript for the first semester and learning cursive letters in the second half of the year (A Reason For, Level T Student Worktext, retrieved October 2026). In the weekly lessons of Level A, students write letters and words from the week’s verse on days 1 through 3, trace the verse on day 4, and on the final day choose a border sheet from the back of the book and write the verse in their best handwriting (A Reason For, Level A Student Worktext, retrieved October 2026). In our assessment, the teacher load is light, and Sonlight lists each student workbook at $23.95 (A Reason for Handwriting at Sonlight, retrieved October 2026).
Pentime
Pentime is a penmanship series spanning grades 1 through 8, available through resellers such as Milestone Books, which lists each Pentime workbook at $6.95 (Milestone Books Pentime Penmanship listing, retrieved October 2026). The Milestone Books listing shows manuscript workbooks for grade 1, a grade 2 transition workbook that gives manuscript practice at the beginning of the term and then switches to beginning cursive and stroke practice, and cursive workbooks for grades 3 through 8. Milestone Books states that minimal teacher assistance is needed and that no teacher’s manuals are necessary (Milestone Books Pentime Penmanship listing, retrieved October 2026), and Rainbow Resource describes the first workbook as showing the correct, numbered strokes for each letter (Rainbow Resource, Pentime handwriting series, retrieved October 2026). In our assessment, it is the most bare-bones option here, suited to families who want inexpensive, no-frills daily penmanship and nothing more. Pentime does not carry an Every Homeschool detail page yet.
Bottom line
In our assessment, for a young child or one who struggles with fine motor control, the multisensory programs, Handwriting Without Tears and Logic of English Rhythm of Handwriting, do the most to build the motor foundation before the workbook stage. For a low-prep, low-cost daily workbook, we find The Good and the Beautiful and A Reason for Handwriting the easiest to run, with the worldview fit deciding between them. We see Memoria Press copybooks as a fit for classical families and Pentime as the inexpensive no-frills fallback. Decide print-first versus cursive-first before you compare brands, because, in our assessment, that choice narrows the field faster than any feature does.
Related reading: the math curriculum pillar and the dyscalculia guide cover the manipulative-first instructional approach in a different subject, and the full publisher directory carries detail pages for four of the six programs named above.
Open reference
Guides, curriculum directory, state laws and ESA tools.
Curriculum reviews, ESA program data, state-law summaries, and plain-English guides to the research that matters. Reader-supported. Always open. No paywall, no email list.